Back to all communications
MODULE 4 · COMMUNICATION

DISQUALIFICATION

Bidder-facingEN+TEDRAFT
From: SYSTEMTo: M/s Marginal Construction Pvt LtdTender: Andhra Pradesh High Court ComplexChannel: EMAIL
Audit ID: 2c156908d936d829

Letter of Disqualification — Tender HC/APCRDA/2026/PROC/001

Date: 2026-05-11

To: M/s Marginal Construction Pvt Ltd

3-5-202, Industrial Area, Vijayawada-520002

Attention: Mr. M. Reddy

Tender: Andhra Pradesh High Court complex

NIT No.: HC/APCRDA/2026/PROC/001


Dear Sir/Madam,

This communication concerns the technical evaluation of your bid submitted for the captioned tender. Following review by the Tender Scrutiny Committee, your bid has been found INELIGIBLE on the following 7 ground(s) (HARD_BLOCK findings under AP procurement norms):

1. Bidder-Personnel-Coverage

  • Rule cited: MPW-041
  • Decision basis: ineligible_4_of_6_roles_filled_vacant_MEP / Electrical Engineer,Surveyor / Total-Station Opera_per_mpw_041_rule_strict
  • Rule text: PQ Criterion (Personnel Capabilities): the applicant's KEY personnel must meet the qualification and experience requirements specified — limited to a small number of key roles (e.g., project/contract manager, superintendents responsible for
  • Finding reference (for verification): 8098e886-82d6-422f-8cdb-8972c4b1ad62

2. Bidder-Turnover-Eligibility

  • Rule cited: CVC-028
  • Decision basis: ineligible_avg_80.0cr_below_pq_floor_243.4cr
  • Rule text: For Civil and Electrical works, the PQ criterion for average annual financial turnover during the last 3 financial years (ending 31 March of the previous FY) shall be at least 30% of the estimated cost of the work.
  • Finding reference (for verification): 0d9c5a28-bc4c-4c02-adf6-407552e077bb

3. Bidder-Class-Eligibility

  • Rule cited: AP-GO-092
  • Decision basis: ineligible_class_Class-I_below_required_Special_per_ap_go_092
  • Rule text: AP Civil Works contractor monetary tendering limits by class (per GO 8/2003): Special > Rs.10 cr; Class-I Rs.2-10 cr; Class-II Rs.1-2 cr; Class-III Rs.50 lakh-1 cr; Class-IV Rs.10-50 lakh; Class-V up to Rs.10 lakh.
  • Finding reference (for verification): 6663033e-624c-4146-bac8-3c0f2a136ae1

4. Bidder-Solvency-Compliance

  • Rule cited: AP-GO-089
  • Decision basis: ineligible_cert_age_14mo_exceeds_12mo_cap_per_ap_go_089
  • Rule text: Solvency Certificate for AP contractor registration is fixed at 10% of the minimum monetary limit of the registered class — issued by Tahsildar (Revenue Dept officer not below Tahsildar rank) OR a Scheduled Bank, valid for ONE YEAR from dat
  • Finding reference (for verification): 3c01af9d-c6a8-4e56-ae19-267ef85d519e

5. Bidder-Capacity-Compliance

  • Rule cited: AP-GO-062
  • Decision basis: ineligible_abc_120.0cr_below_ecv_365.16cr
  • Rule text: Available Bid Capacity for AP Works = (A × N × 2) − B, where A = max civil-engineering works value executed in any one year of last 5 years (price-updated), N = number of years for completion, B = value of existing commitments due in same p
  • Finding reference (for verification): 85e2d955-61ec-4295-a6f6-d1f15392f4b5

6. Bidder-Similar-Works-Qualification

  • Rule cited: MPW-040
  • Decision basis: ineligible_no_branch_satisfied_3@40pct_count1of3required_threshold146.064cr+2@50pct_count1of2required_threshold182.58cr+1@80pct_count0of1required_threshold292.128cr
  • Rule text: PQ Criterion 2 (Particular Construction Experience): applicant must have successfully or substantially completed similar works during last 7 years ending last day of the month previous to the application — meeting EITHER (i) THREE similar w
  • Finding reference (for verification): 1f9bffe4-dd14-4d16-9dc7-dfd3f2f969ac

7. Bidder-Financial-Turnover-Eligibility

  • Rule cited: MPG-255
  • Decision basis: ineligible_financial_56.0cr_below_floor_109.55cr_per_mpg_255
  • Rule text: Pre-Qualification Criterion 3 (Financial Standing): the average annual financial turnover of the bidder over the last three years ending 'The Relevant Date' must be at the specified Rs. millions threshold (or equivalent foreign currency at
  • Finding reference (for verification): ea5824c7-eea6-4f28-85a9-ea09aebdddd1

Per the AP Standard Tender Document and CVC procurement norms, any HARD_BLOCK finding renders the bid INELIGIBLE for the present tender. Your Earnest Money Deposit (EMD) will be refunded per the standard EMD return procedure within 21 days of the issue of this letter, subject to no withholding orders.

Right to representation

If you believe any of the findings above is factually incorrect, you may submit a written representation within 7 days of receipt of this letter to the Procuring Authority. Each representation must:

  • Cite the specific finding reference (e.g. BidEvaluationFinding <node_id>) being disputed
  • Provide supporting documentation addressing the rule and decision basis
  • Be signed by the authorised signatory on record (Form-12 declaration)

Representations received after 7 days will not be entertained except under exceptional circumstances per CVC vigilance norms.


Yours faithfully,

Procuring Authority

(Communication generated by SYSTEM; signed-off via approval workflow before dispatch)

Drilldown reference:

  • EligibilityMatrix node_id: b5505ca3-ed39-4ef8-8c75-af2a34b0d3d2
  • Aggregate verdict: DISQUALIFIED (6 QUALIFIED + 7 HARD_BLOCK + 0 WARNING + 0 GAP)
  • Findings consumed: 7 HARD_BLOCK + EligibilityMatrix = 8 kg_nodes

Source Findings (8)

Every claim in this communication traces to one of these kg_nodes. Click to view the underlying evaluation finding or aggregator row.

BidEvaluationFinding8098e886-82d
Bidder-Personnel-Coverage: M/s Marginal Construction Pvt Ltd 4/6 roles filled → INELIGIBLE
Rule: MPW-041 · ineligible_4_of_6_roles_filled_vacant_MEP / Electrical Engineer,Surveyor / Total-Station Opera_per_mpw_041_rule_strict
Drilldown
BidEvaluationFinding0d9c5a28-bc4
Bidder-Turnover-Eligibility: M/s Marginal Construction Pvt Ltd avg ₹80.0cr < PQ floor ₹243.4cr → INELIGIBLE
Rule: CVC-028 · ineligible_avg_80.0cr_below_pq_floor_243.4cr
Drilldown
BidEvaluationFinding6663033e-624
Bidder-Class-Eligibility: M/s Marginal Construction Pvt Ltd class Class-I < required Special → INELIGIBLE
Rule: AP-GO-092 · ineligible_class_Class-I_below_required_Special_per_ap_go_092
Drilldown
BidEvaluationFinding3c01af9d-c6a
Bidder-Solvency-Compliance: M/s Marginal Construction Pvt Ltd cert Bank 14mo ₹0.2cr/₹0.2cr → INELIGIBLE
Rule: AP-GO-089 · ineligible_cert_age_14mo_exceeds_12mo_cap_per_ap_go_089
Drilldown
BidEvaluationFinding85e2d955-61e
Bidder-Capacity-Compliance: M/s Marginal Construction Pvt Ltd ABC ₹120.0cr < ECV ₹365.16cr (M=2) → INELIGIBLE
Rule: AP-GO-062 · ineligible_abc_120.0cr_below_ecv_365.16cr
Drilldown
BidEvaluationFinding1f9bffe4-dd1
Bidder-Similar-Works-Qualification: M/s Marginal Construction Pvt Ltd 1 works recompute_qualified=False → INELIGIBLE
Rule: MPW-040 · ineligible_no_branch_satisfied_3@40pct_count1of3required_threshold146.064cr+2@50pct_count1of2required_threshold182.58cr+
Drilldown
BidEvaluationFindingea5824c7-eea
Bidder-Financial-Turnover-Eligibility: M/s Marginal Construction Pvt Ltd financial-3yr ₹56.0cr < floor ₹109.55cr → INELIGIBLE
Rule: MPG-255 · ineligible_financial_56.0cr_below_floor_109.55cr_per_mpg_255
Drilldown
EligibilityMatrixb5505ca3-ed3
EligibilityMatrix: M/s Marginal Construction Pvt Ltd → hc — DISQUALIFIED (7 HB)
Drilldown

Artifact files

Filesystem paths (also linked to kg_node properties)

Markdown
/tmp/m4_drafts/DISQUALIFICATION_b2_hc.md
DOCX
/tmp/m4_drafts/DISQUALIFICATION_b2_hc.docx