Back to all tenders
MODULE 3 · EVALUATION REPORT
Andhra Pradesh Judicial Academy
NIT:
JA/2026/CW/001ECV: ₹125.50 crBidders: 9Effective L1 (post-anomaly adjustment)
M/s Comprehensive Standard Builders JV (Premier Coastal + Northern Engineering + Southern Surveys)
Award amount: ₹117.97 cr
L1 (M/s Abnormally Low Bidders Pvt Ltd) ALB-rejected per CVC norms; cartel-suspect bidders (bid_synth_profile_b6, bid_synth_profile_b7) referred to committee; first non-skipped bidder in ranking = M/s Comprehensive Standard Builders JV (Premier Coastal + Northern Engineering + Southern Surveys).
Bidder Participation (9)
| Bidder | Verdict | Qualified | Hard-Block | Warning | Gap | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
M/s Premier AP Constructions Pvt Ltd Special | Qualified | 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Details |
M/s Marginal Construction Pvt Ltd Class-I | Disqualified | 7 | 6 | 0 | 0 | Details |
M/s Anomalous Builders LLP Special | Disqualified | 4 | 8 | 1 | 0 | Details |
M/s Borderline Litigation Builders Pvt Ltd Special | Flagged for Review | 12 | 0 | 1 | 0 | Details |
M/s Incomplete Submissions Corp Pvt Ltd Special | Documentation Review | 12 | 0 | 0 | 1 | Details |
M/s Cartel Alpha Construction Pvt Ltd Special | Qualified | 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Details |
M/s Cartel Beta Construction Pvt Ltd Special | Qualified | 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Details |
M/s Abnormally Low Bidders Pvt Ltd Special | Qualified | 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Details |
M/s Comprehensive Standard Builders JV (Premier Coastal + Northern Engineering + Southern Surveys) Special | Qualified | 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Details |
Ranking of QUALIFIED Bidders (5)
| Rank | Bidder | Bid Amount | Premium vs ECV | ALB? | Distance from L1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| L1 | M/s Abnormally Low Bidders Pvt Ltd | ₹77.81 cr | -38.00% | ALB | — |
| L2 | M/s Comprehensive Standard Builders JV (Premier Coastal + Northern Engineering + Southern Surveys) | ₹117.97 cr | -6.00% | — | +₹40.16 cr (+51.61%) |
| L3 | M/s Premier AP Constructions Pvt Ltd | ₹119.22 cr | -5.00% | — | +₹41.41 cr (+53.22%) |
| L4 | M/s Cartel Alpha Construction Pvt Ltd | ₹121.61 cr | -3.10% | — | +₹43.80 cr (+56.29%) |
| L5 | M/s Cartel Beta Construction Pvt Ltd | ₹121.67 cr | -3.05% | — | +₹43.86 cr (+56.37%) |
ALB action required: raw L1 (M/s Abnormally Low Bidders Pvt Ltd) is an ALB candidate. Effective L1 falls to the next non-skipped bidder.
Anomaly Findings (2)
CARTEL_SUSPECT
HIGHPrimary bidders: M/s Cartel Alpha Construction Pvt Ltd, M/s Cartel Beta Construction Pvt Ltd
Confidence: HIGH · Cross-tender: 3/3 consistent
CARTEL_SUSPECT — M/s Cartel Alpha Construction Pvt Ltd + M/s Cartel Beta Construction Pvt Ltd share 4 signal(s) (SHARED_ADDRESS + MATCHED_SIGNATORY + COMMON_BANK_BRANCH + SEQUENTIAL_BIDS); cross-tender consistency: pair QUALIFIED on 3 of 3 tender(s)
Signals (4)
SHARED_ADDRESS
Both bidders' communication_address = '4-7-89, Industrial Estate, Guntur-522001'
MATCHED_SIGNATORY
Signatories share 'R.' prefix: A='Mr. R. Sharma', B='Mr. R. Patel'
COMMON_BANK_BRANCH
Both BGs issued by 'State Bank of India, Vijayawada Main Branch'
SEQUENTIAL_BIDS
Premium deltas within 0.05% (A=-3.1%, B=-3.05%) at adjacent ranks L4+L5
ALB_CORROBORATION
HIGHPrimary bidders: M/s Abnormally Low Bidders Pvt Ltd
Confidence: HIGH · Cross-tender: 3/3 consistent
ALB_CORROBORATION — bidder M/s Abnormally Low Bidders Pvt Ltd on tender tender_synth_ja: flagged ALB across 3 of 3 tender(s); cross-tender consistency True.
Signals (1)
ALB_CROSS_TENDER_PATTERN
Bidder flagged ALB on 3 of 3 tender(s) (['tender_synth_hc', 'tender_synth_ja', 'tender_synth_kurnool']); on this tender bid ₹77.81cr at premium -38.0%.
ComparativeStatement Artifacts
Audit ID:
a911ac49b4b90bacMarkdown
/tmp/comparative_statements/tender_synth_ja.mdDOCX
/tmp/comparative_statements/tender_synth_ja.docxPDF (L75 reportlab)
/tmp/comparative_statements/tender_synth_ja.pdf